2022 Pumpkin Picking Guide | Sayville Patchogue Moms

With October right around the corner, we are so excited to share with you our pumpkin picking guide! In no particular order, we’ve compiled a list of TWENTY places on Long Island to get your pumpkins! Whether you’re looking for an all day adventure, or a quick stop in town, we’ve got you covered.

Waterdrinker Family Farm
Address: 663 Wading River Road, Manorville
Phone: 631-878-8653
Additional Information: M-F $15 pp, Sat & Sun $20, Children under 2 free. *Admission to pumpkin patch only is free.
-Admission includes: hay rides (Sat & Sun), jumbo jump pad, mini golf, barnyard animals, lawn games, wooden play land, tractor pedal cars. corn maze, lost island tortoise enclosure and more!
-Check out Long Island Farm Brewery while you’re there!

Elwood Pumpkin Farm
Address: 1500 E. Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743
Phone Number: 631-368-8626
Hours: Weekends 10 AM-5 PM beginning 9/24 & Weekdays 3-5 beginning 10/3
Additional Information:
-Can pick a pumpkin straight from the vine
-Pumpkins are priced by size
-Wagon rides and corn maze available for a fee
-Cash only

F & W Schmitt’s Family Farm
Address: 26 Pinelawn Rd, Melville NY 11747
Phone Number: 631-271-3276
Hours: Weekends 10 AM-5 PM &Weekdays 12-5 from 9/17-10/30
Additional Information:
-Free parking
-$15 admission includes a hayride, mini golf, playground & photo opps (Children under 16 months free)
-For additional fees they offer pumpkin picking, sunflower and vegetable picking, pony rides, petting zoo, concessions, corn maze, and more.

Organics Today Farm
Address: 169 Washington Street, East Islip
Phone Number: 631-480-6497
Hours: Every day of the week 9-6, Saturdays in October stay open until 9 PM
Additional Information:
-Free admission every day
-Open every day 9 AM-6 PM for pumpkin picking and hay rides from September 26-October 31st
-Offer moonlight pumpkin picking every Saturday night in October from 6 PM-9 PM, family friendly!

Stakey’s Pumpkin Farm
Address: 270 West Lane, Riverhead
Phone Number: 631-722-3467
Hours: Weekdays 12-5 & Weekends 9-5
Additional Information:
-Hay rides, corn maze, & face painting available for additional price. Country store and flower house on site.
-Pumpkins priced $0.79 per pound
-Accepts credit and debit cards

Milk Pail U-Pick Farm
Address: 50 Horsemill Lane, Watermill
Phone Number: 631-537-2565
Hours: Friday, Saturday & Sunday plus holidays from 10 AM-5:30 PM
Additional Information:
Varieties of U-pick pumpkins & U-Pick apples available. Credit cards accepted, free parking.

Fink’s Family Farm
Address: 6242 Middle Country Road, Wading River
Phone Number: 631-886-2272
Hours: Weekends only 9:30-5 PM, September 11-October 31
Additional Information:
-Hay rides, corn maze, U-pick pumpkins, kiddy train ride, combine slide and much more!
-Handicapped accessible, including our hayrides, corn maze and bathroom facilities.
-Picnic area (outside food permitted)
-Food and refreshments are available, including roasted corn and hot cider.
-Fall Barnyard open M-F (excluding Holidays) $10.00 pp (ages 2 and under free) with U-Pick pumpkins available for purchase-no fall festival activities or food vendors offered.
-Weekend pricing: 2 and under free, 3 and up $18, Senior/Military/Law Enforcement/Fire $15
-Free admission M-F after 3 PM through October only.

Lewin Farms
Address: 812 Sound Avenue, Calverton
Phone Number: 631-929-4327
Hours: Lewin Farms recommends you call each day for schedule, but typically open from 9-4:40.
Additional Information:
-Cash only (ATM available)
-Corn maze open weekends 10-4:30 PM

Glover Farms
Address: 641 Victory Avenue, Brookhaven
Phone Number: 631-286-7876
Hours: Opens September 24th, Monday – Friday 2pm-6pm, Saturday & Sunday 10am – 6pm
Additional Information:
-Pick the perfect pumpkin and then explore their 10 acre corn maze
-Farm animals available to feed

Mays Farm
Address: 6361 RT 25A, Wading River
Phone Number: 631-929-6654
Hours:  9-6 Mon-Sat, 9-5 Sun
Additional Information:
-Hayrides and corn maze
-Available at farm stand: mums, corn stalks, straw bails, fall decorations and fresh picked fruits and vegetables

Harbes Farms Jamesport
Address: 1223 Main Road, Jamesport
Phone Number: 631-494-4796
Hours: Open weekends & Holidays 9-6
Additional Information:
-Acres of pumpkin picking & apple picking
-Hay ride & a corn maze
-Fall treats available to purchase such as roasted corn and apple cider doughnuts
-Pumpkins sold by the pound

Harbes Orchard
Address: 5698 Sound Avenue, Mattituck
Phone Number: 631-683-8388
Hours: Open weekends and holidays 9-6
Additional Information:
-9 acres of U-pick pumpkins
-Pumpkins sold by the pound
**Requires purchasing an apple picking package to pick pumpkins

Harbes Family Farm
Address: 715 Sound Ave., Mattituck
Phone Number: 631-482-7641
Hours: Open daily 10-6
Additional Information:
-8 acres of U-pick pumpkins
-Mattituck Farm stand located across the street
-Pumpkins sold by the pound
–Fall pricing: M-F $14.95 pp, Weekends and Holidays Barnyard Only $23.95 PP, Combo with musical hayride, $28.95 pp

Hanks Pumpkintown
Address: 240 Montauk Hwy, Watermill
Phone Number: 631-726-4667
Hours: Open daily 9:30-5:30
Additional Information:
-U-pick pumpkins (no admission cost for the pumpkin patch), pumpkins priced $0.79 per pound
-Apple picking only available Saturday and Sunday
-Admission to Hanks Pumpkintown Maze Park on weekends and holidays is $20 pp and includes corn mazes, wagon rides, cow milking, giant mountain slide, jump pad, wooden play structures and more (Children under 2 free), $14 pp Non-Holiday weekday.

Schmitt Family Farm on Bagatelle
Address: 6 Bagatelle Road, Dix Hills
Phone Number: 631-549-3276
Hours: Open Monday-Wednesday 10-5, Thursday-Sunday 10-6
Additional Information:
-$5 dollar admission fee for pumpkin patch which includes duck races and photo opportunities
-Animal train ride and hayrides are available for a fee
-Fall themed treats available for purchase including apple cider doughnuts, roasted corn, apple cider, and fresh baked pies

Brightwaters Farms
Address: 1624 Manatuck Blvd, Bay Shore
Phone Number: 631-665-5411
Fall Harvest begins 10/1-10/30. $20 per person on weekends & Columbus Day 9 am – 5 pm
Additional Information:
Weekday Schedule (excluding Columbus Day)
-No charge for admission
Pumpkin picking, Farm animal feeding, farm playground, hayrides
-Country Store Open Wednesday to Sunday
Weekend & Columbus Day Schedule
-$20.00 Admission per person, under 1 year old is free
-Admission Includes:
Unlimited Hayrides, Farm Playground, Cartoon Characters, Animal Viewing, Live entertainment, Full Concession Menu, Pumpkin Picking. Pony Rides, Farm Animal Feeding, Full Concession Menu

Lenny Bruno Farms
Address: 740 Wading River Road, Manorville
Phone Number: 631-591-3592
Hours: Open every day 9-6
Additional Information:
-8 acres of U-pick
-Corn maze, fall treats including apple cider, hot roasted corn, bounce house and petting zoo on the weekends

The Farm on Lakeland
Address: 109 Lakeland Avenue, Sayville
Phone Number: 516-695-5443
Hours: Every day 10-5
Additional Information:
-Varieties of pumpkins
-Corn stalks, hay bales, and other fall decor available in addition to fresh produce

White Post Farms
Address: 250 Old Country Road, Melville
Phone Number: 631-351-9373
Hours: Weekends & Columbus Day
Sept. 18, 19, 25, 26, Oct. 2, 3
Gates open 10am-4pm Stay until 6pm

Weekends & Columbus Day
Sept. 24, 25, Oct. 1, 2, 8, 9, 10, 15, 16, 22, 28, 29, 30
Gates open 9:30am-4:30pm Stay until 6pm

Additional Information:
-Festival admission is 34.95 + tax for adults and children 15 months and older
-Admission includes: White Post Animal Farm, unlimited hay rides, Play in the Hay activity, family shows, outdoor picnic areas
-Pumpkins, Pony rides, train rides, and feed the animals are available at an additional cost

The Dee’s Nursery and Florist
Address: 69 Atlantic Ave., Oceanside
Phone Number:(516)-678-3535
Hours: Weekends 10-5
Additional Information:
Family Festival and Petting Zoo Entrance Fee: $14.99 –
This Fee provides entrance to the festival, unlimited entrance to Spooky Walk, Interactive Petting Zoo, animal feed included, and kiddie slide.
(Family group up to 6 people – $3.99 each additional person.)
-For additional costs-pumpkin painting, gem & fossil mining

Fairview Farm
Address: 69 Horsemill Lane, Bridgehampton
Hours: Weekends, Labor Day, and Columbus Day 10-6, 9/3-11/6
Additional Information:
-Stroller and wheelchair accessible
-General admission is $14, 11 and under $12, 3 and under free
-Corn maze, pumpkin picking and food concessions

Join The Sayville-Patchogue Area Moms Network Community

Stay up-to-date with what is happening in-and-around The Sayville Patchogue Area Moms Network community with local events, community highlights, and exclusive deals.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to stay in the loop! Our newsletter is filled with hacks, recipes, coupons/deals & more!

You have Successfully Subscribed!