2025 Shop Small Shop Local Holiday Guide

November 13, 2025

Posted In: Guides

This holiday season, come together to support local businesses by participating in #ShopSmallLongIsland.

This time of year is a great opportunity to explore new stores, especially when holiday shopping for others. Another advantage is the level of customer service when purchasing from a local retailer. Looking for a specific shoe or bottle of wine? A local business is much more helpful in tracking down exactly what you need. And if they don’t have what you are looking for, they may be able to refer you to another local business who may have the item in stock.

Salty Isla

Welcome to SALTY ISLA. We are located at 44. S. Main Street in Sayville, NY.

We are the first permanent jewelry shop in Sayville. We have a great selection of chains and charms. We carry sterling silver, gold filled, and 14K gold.   We thrive on customer service and are 100% sure that  your experience at Salty Isla will be incredible. 

In addition to permanent jewelry, we  carry our own hand-made jewelry brand, Swank Stones, & we offer fun jewelry by INK + ALLOY, and  GORJANA. We also have a charm bar and a build your own bracelet experience. Come check out our new, beautiful, embroidered hoodies. 

Follow on Instagram
check out the website here for all holiday gifts

Mixers and Elixiers by Dev

Mixers and Elixirs by Dev creates fresh, non-alcoholic, cocktail and mocktail mixers for making bar quality drinks at home. Each is made from freshly squeezed, seasonal, fruit juice, and unique simple syrups. Add your favorite spirits, seltzers, or enjoy as is!

Perfect for parties, gatherings, girl’s night, or date night.

contact on for more info on the website
Visit Instagram here

Village

Village is a multifacted and thoughtfully curated retail shop located on the south shore of Long Island NY, in Sayville.

We cater to the women and mothers of our community. At Village we aspire to serve as a dedicated support system and become a landing place for gift giving, relationship building, self care, and education.

Check out our beautiful products Tuesday-Sunday and be on the lookout for upcoming events!

check out the website here for all holiday gifts
Visit Instagram here

South Shore Scents Co.

We’re South Shore Scents Co. — candles made by hand on Long Island, inspired by the cozy moments that make a house feel like home. We create candles with clean, sustainable ingredients and timeless scents — each one poured by hand to bring warmth and relaxation and a little everyday comfort into your home.

The glow of a candle. The sound of laughter. The feeling of home.
Our Holiday Collection was poured with those moments in mind — the ones that take you back to the magic of simpler days and make you pause, smile, and remember.

 

check out the website here for all holiday gifts
Visit Instagram here

Salty Paws Pet Boutique

We are a pet boutique in Bellport village 🐾
We have goodies for your dogs, cats & the pawrents too!
13 Bellport Lane, Bellport NY 11713
We can ship!
 

Follow on Instagram
Visit the website here

Home Long Island

Elise started out painting wooden home signs as a way to fill her need for a creative outlet. With encouragement from friends and family, she began a business and started selling signs on Etsy. After realizing her design was a hit, she trademarked the home logo and added it to apparel.

With the support of amazing customers, the business grew from decor to clothing, accessories, and more. With the exciting impending arrival of her first child, Elise had an amazing opportunity to step away and focus on her family, which is when Maria stepped in...

As it’s new owner, Maria is excited to expand the HOME brand into other categories including baby & kids, athleisure, accessories, glassware, personalized gifts and so much more!

Outside of running the business, you can sweat with Maria at CycleBar Sayville. Catch an episode of her Fitness Podcast on Spotify or slide into her DMs on Instagram @costello_maria_ and share with her why you love the HOME brand.

Follow on Instagram
Visit the website here

#ShopSmallLongIsland this holiday season

This guide contains sponsored content.

We are incredibly grateful for our amazing community and the wonderful people and places that make it so special. Explore our Community Resource Page for featuring business in the area that are MUSTS to check out.

What Is Happening Around Sayville Patchogue Moms

A smiling woman enjoying seaside scenery in Ocean City, Maryland, with ocean views and greenery.

Meet a Mom: Bridget Finder

Meet Bridget Finder, local mom, school principal, and founder of Ultimate Getaway Finder. From family adventures and girls’ getaways to luxury escapes and multi-generational vacations, Bridget helps busy families turn travel dreams into meaningful memories.

Fresh produce at Ocean City farm stand with seasonal blooms and family-friendly atmosphere.

Local Farm Stands

Whether you’re picking up fresh vegetables, local honey, or flowers for the kitchen table, these South Shore farm stands are worth a visit. Here’s your guide from Sayville to Brookhaven.