Lucky Charms Ice Cream Sandwiches!

March 8, 2025

Posted In: Recipes

Lucky Charms ice cream sandwiches

This story originally appeared on The Local Moms Network.

We just might skip green beer this year and swap in these instagram-worthy St. Patrick's Day-inspired Lucky Charm's ice cream sandwiches from South Orange County Moms! Don't have Lucky Charms? Use any colorful cereal you've stocked up on!

 

Ingredients:

  • Sugar Cookie - Cookie Dough (you can certainly make sugar cookies from scratch. I saved a couple steps by using Pillsbury ready-made sugar cookie dough).
  • Green Food Coloring
  • Lucky Charms
  • Vanilla Ice Cream

Steps:

  1. Put the pre-made sugar cookie dough in a bowl and add green food coloring. Add as much food coloring as you need, until the whole batch is green.
  2. Cook the sugar cookies per the instructions on the wrapper.
  3. Let the cookies cool.
  4. Take some slightly soft vanilla ice cream and scoop it on to the bottom side of one cookie.
  5. Place another cookie on top and then take the lucky charms and place them in the ice cream around the entire edge of the cookie.

 

Lucky Charms ice cream sandwiches

Recipe c/o our sister site South Orange County Moms Network

Read more from the Local Moms Network:

Pot of Gold Cookies from The BakerMama

St. Patrick's Day Cupcakes from Emma Heming Willis

St. Patrick’s Day Cocktails & Mocktails

What Is Happening Around Sayville Patchogue Moms

Woman practicing yoga in a bright, modern living room with cozy decor.

Meet a Mom: Deidre Woll

Meet the mom behind Heal With Deidre, bringing wellness, mindfulness, and meaningful self-care experiences to our local community.

A woman smiling in professional attire, representing Ocean City Moms community.

Meet a Mom: Christine Earls

Meet local mom Christine Earls, founder of You and Me By The Sea Travel, whose passion for family, community, and meaningful travel helps families create memories that last a lifetime.